I did spent some time to read as much as I could on this thread and I only have to say one thing.
When rules are being broken, it's up to the people in charge to make decisions, pass punishment, as they see fit.
Knowingly braking the rules is actually looking for trouble. As it seems, certain players found their way to that sort of trouble.
So it was up to the people in charge (immstaff and finally Dulrik) to pass the punishment as they saw fit.
Reasoning these people abused a known bug, looking for trouble, they passed out max punishment.
I don't see how complaining on their behalf here will make it any easier on them, or benefit anyone.
Were I one of the punished, and assuming I cared about the punishment, I would take it up explaining to D, via mail.
I still don't see why all the fuss about the issue. This is no courtroom to file an appeal. It's someone's game with a specific ruleset, which he/they enforce as he/they see fit. End of story.
Move along now, nothing more to see here!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/df1d7/df1d7327d5ddf35cef19a5e318dcf46648aa9c94" alt="8)"